Gerber Prodigy Review

Gerber’s ubiquitous Prodigy knife is an enigma.  On the one hand, this survival and military styled knife is priced for the entry-level user while boasting a robust list of features aimed at higher level users.  But on the other, one must weigh some of Gerber’s newer knife offerings such as the tarnished Bear Grylls line which call into question this companies ability to produce worthy products.  Let’s take a closer look at the Prodigy:

420 HC Steel has become more popular over the last 5-10 years having been adopted by Buck Knives, Strider, Condor, several smaller brands as well as OEM-fresh-from-China-no-name blades.  Known for its mediocre edge retention, this lower cost tool steel has extra chromium to increase corrosion resistance and added carbon for cutting power.  Heat treatment is everything and the question is whether or not Gerber has successfully  implemented the steel in their products.  We will find out in the video below.

“MIRS Compliant” – OK, so it meets some little known military standard for knives.  Not sure what that means and one would guess most similar knives are MIRS compliant as well so we won’t dwell long on this clever bit of marketing.

The Prodigy’s sheath is rubberized and includes a leg strap along with nylon attachment points for molle-compatability.  The nylon portion is not done particularly well but it is done and by itself this sheath would probably run $25 retail.  Remember, this is a $45-$50 knife that includes the sheath.

The rubberized handle is super grip-worthy and to be honest I have ZERO complaints.  In fact, it’s rather nice.  A full-length, through tang protrudes from the butt of the Prodigy in the form of a lanyard loop and glass breaker.  But there’s more to like here such as the blade’s black ceramic coating and 1/2 serrated edge .

However, without edge durability and performance the Gerber Prodigy could be all hat and no cowboy.  Check out the video below as I put its through its paces and then some to see if Gerber’s seemingly faltering reputation as a knife maker is deserved.

This entry was posted in Product Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Gerber Prodigy Review

  1. Tom K says:

    You just convinced me to buy a second prodigy.

  2. Tom K says:

    I’m really surprised you weren’t more enthusiastic about this blade considering its price tag & the fact most people would never put their blade through that amount abuse & I don’t think many blades in this price range (and many more expensive)would survive that amount abuse.
    Thanks for the fine review.

    • Greenbeetle says:

      It seems like a lot of knife for the money. My only reservations are that it is 1/2 serrated (I don’t care for serrations) and the steel which is mid-grade at its best.

  3. Craig Benno says:

    I bought mine at a 1/2 price sale in Australia for $60 bucks. I’m happy as with it as a general purpose camping / survival knife. But, its not so great for skinning and general hunting purposes, as the serrations get in the way. But for that, I like to use my small Swiss army pocket knife.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s